THE SPOT: One Girl Cookies has been one of my favorite Brooklyn neighborhood spots for years and years occupying a sleepy side street in Cobble Hill and beloved by the community. When visiting this mom and pop (husband and wife, actually) business on my own or with tour groups, I mostly focus on their solid repertoire of mini cookies but every once in a while I notice something new on their display case. I was shocked and super excited when I saw a basket of black and whites calling my name.
At the time, this was an extension of a Valentine’s Day special but the owner (and “one girl”) Dawn told me they are quite labor intensive so whether they will be a regular occurrence is uncertain. I can’t guarantee they are currently available, but it is worth a visit regularly to find out.
THE BLACK: The chocolate was fudgy rather than fondant-like and a prime example of why I almost always prefer the dark side of these cookies.
THE WHITE: The white was more firm and sugary, but not overly sweet.
THE COOKIE: As the business’ name implies, the cookie itself is kind of what they do best. And this cookie (or cake) was no exception. I love that their cookies are smaller and less guilt-filled (at least that’s what I tell myself). This one was pretty traditional with a hit of lemon and a very soft, moist cake-quality. It didn’t have any browned exterior, but that was clearly on purpose and gives it the authentic black and white experience.
THE RATING: I love the nostalgic authenticity and the miniature nature of these cookies. I give them a solid 8 out of 10.
| ONE GIRL COOKIES |
| 68 Dean Street (between Smith Street and Boerum Place), Cobble Hill Brooklyn (212) 675-4996 |
| onegirlcookies.com |
