Bagels

BAGELS in New York: Caputo Bagels

7.5

THE SPOT: I was very eager to try Caputo Bagels which is a somewhat surprising transition from historic Italian bakery to local bagel shop.

This new location is bright and clean and you can almost smell the new coat of paint as employees wander around somewhat aimlessly and bags of flour sit on display. That is not a criticism but rather a comment about the visibility into this community oriented business.

The bagels are treated like baked goods on display above the banana walnut bread. If you hadn’t told me, I would mistake this for a coffee shop rather than a bagel store. And maybe that’s what they’re going for since there are a number of tables and a fresh-squeezed orange juice machine.

One thing I noticed on their menu is that in addition to classic bagels, they offer a lard bagel. I probably should have stuck to the classic for a true test, but the lard one sounded too interesting to pass up.

THE CHEW: Lard bread is not uncommon to find on special occasions at Italian-American bakeries in Brooklyn and the Bronx, but this is the first I’ve seen it encroaching bagel territory. In fact, some Jewish bagel purists might think the addition of rendered pork fat and pig bits throughout sacrilegious. And technically it is, but the majority of bagel eaters in this part of Brooklyn don’t care. Bacon is as common nowadays as lox. And I think it’s neat that other cultures are embracing and re-inventing the bagel which is as New York as it is Jewish.

All that being said, the lard bagel felt more like a good lard bread in the shape of a bagel than an actual bagel. It didn’t have that puffy chew or bite that I expect from a proper bagel. It did have plenty of flavor from salami, provolone cheese, and black pepper.

I wasn’t sure what cream cheese to use and it almost felt like that might be too much. The cashiers suggested the harissa cream cheese, which is also unusual and brings in another culture (North African). I think it got lost a bit with the strong flavors from the pork bits in the bagel because I couldn’t taste much spice.

This is certainly worth a try, but more to get a taste of what Caputo’s did for the last century.

I did also pick up one of their everything bagels to eat at home. Generally, I don’t like to rate next-day bagels since they should always be made fresh and on-premises in New York. I won’t go too far into it, but I was impressed by the amount of seasoning and how the softness of the bagel held up the next day.

The bagel world is vast and so, while not everything here works as a bagel for me, I applaud Caputo for trying something new and growing the bagel experience.

7.5

CAPUTO BAGELS
81 5th Avenue (between Prospect Place and Park Place),
Park Slope, Brooklyn
(347) 464-3323
caputobagels.com

AboutBrian Hoffman

Brian Hoffman is a classically trained actor who is now a full-time tour guide, blogger, and food obsessive. He leads food and drink tours around New York City, which not only introduce tour-goers to delicious food, but gives them a historical context. He has written food articles for Gothamist and Midtown Lunch in addition to overseeing this blog and a few food video series, including Eat This, Locals Know, and Around the World in One City. His latest series is an international cooking show with his son which can be found on this site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *