CURRENT STANDINGS (OUT OF 10 POINTS):


Click on a link to see a review and photos….

ABSOLUTE BAGELS (NOW CLOSED) – 9

BAGEL OASIS – 9

ESS-A-BAGEL – 9

MURRAY’S BAGELS – 9

POPUP BAGELS – 9

APOLLO BAGELS – 8.5

SHELSKY’S BROOKLYN BAGELS – 8.5

BAGEL BOY – 8

BEST BAGEL AND COFFEE – 8

BROOKLYN BAGEL & COFFEE COMPANY – 8

DAVID’S BAGELS – 8

DYKER PARK BAGELS – 8

H & H BAGELS (NOW CLOSED) – 8

HOT BIALYS & BAGELS – 8

LEO’S BAGELS – 8

LIBERTY BAGELS – 8

TERRACE BAGELS – 8

MODERN BREAD & BAGEL (GLUTEN FREE) – 7.5

TOMPKINS SQUARE BAGELS – 7.5

THE BAGEL HOLE – 7

BAGELS & SCHMEAR – 7

BAGELWORKS – 7

BLACK SEED BAGELS – 7

HOT JUMBO BAGELS – 7

LONG ISLAND BAGEL CAFE (NOW CLOSED) – 7

MOCHA BAGELS – 7

MONTAGUE STREET BAGELS – 7

TAL BAGELS – 7

ZUCKER’S BAGELS & SMOKED FISH – 7

BAGEL PUB – 6.5

BROWNS BAGELS (NOW CLOSED) – 6

DAVIDOVICH BAKERY – 6

PICK-A-BAGEL – 6

ROLEN BAGELS – 6

VIC’S BAGEL BAR – 6 (NOW CLOSED)

COURT STREET BAGELS – 5

LA BAGEL DELIGHT – 5

KOSSAR’S BIALYS – 4

3 Comments

  1. Thanks for your comment. I do try to keep this as up to date as possible, but of course, being just one person, it’s impossible to try everything. My lists are ever-changing and evolving and I have some more bagel reviews on the horizon.

    What are some of your top spots that you think should be on this list or not?

  2. Thanks for your comment. What specifically do you feel is out of date? I do my best to keep this up to date but it is a running of all the bagel shops I’ve reviewed in NYC and I have not made it to all of them, of course. I agree some need to be re-visited and newer ones continue to get added. What do you think is missing?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *